Tamil Diplomat

Russian airliner ‘broke up in mid-air’

A Russian airliner which crashed in Egypt’s Sinai peninsula, killing all 224 people on board, broke up in mid-air, a Russian official says.

Victor Sorochenko, the head of Russia’s Interstate Aviation Committee, said it was too early to conclude what caused the crash on Saturday.

He told reporters debris was found across a 20sq km-wide area of Sinai. So far 163 bodies have been found.

Russia observed a day of mourning on Sunday after its worst air disaster.

Mr Sorochenko spoke after visiting the site of the debris, near the village of Hasana. The head of Russia’s Air Transport Agency, Aleksandr Neradko, said that “all signs attest to the fact that the aircraft disintegrated in the air at a high altitude”.


Jihadists allied to so-called Islamic State in Sinai, where such groups are active, had made a claim on social media that they had brought down flight KGL9268.

But Egyptian Prime Minister Sharif Ismail said experts had confirmed that a plane could not be downed at 9,450m (31,000ft), the altitude the Airbus 321 was flying at, by weapons the militants are known to possess.

President Abdul Fattah al-Sisi also urged caution on Sunday, saying the investigation into the cause was a “complicated matter” that could take months.

Russian Transport Minister Maksim Sokolov said no evidence had been seen that indicated the plane was targeted, and IS has not produced pictures or video footage to substantiate its claim.

Analysis by BBC Monitoring found that a video purporting to show the downing of a plane did not appear to be an official IS clip, and was not shared on official IS channels.


A number of major airlines – Emirates, Air France-KLM, Lufthansa, and Qatar Airways – have decided not to fly over the Sinai Peninsula until more information is available. Two smaller carriers, flydubai and Air Arabia, also said they would re-route flights, while Etihad Airways said it would avoid only “certain areas of airspace” over Sinai.

Germany’s transport ministry has told German airlines not to follow the same route taken by the Russian plane.

British Airways said it regularly assessed the safety of its routes. BA said it would not confirm flight routes, but that it “would never fly a route unless it was safe to do so”.

The plane came down early on Saturday, shortly after leaving the resort of Sharm el-Sheikh for the Russian city of St Petersburg.

Russian and French investigators have joined the Egyptian-led probe, along with experts from Airbus, which is headquartered in France.

Egyptian officials said some bodies had been recovered within a radius of 5km on Saturday, but that of a three-year-old girl was found 8km from the scene.

One unnamed official told Reuters the plane appeared to have split in two, with one part burning up and the other crashing into a rock.

The plane’s flight recorders have been found and sent for analysis, officials said.

Russia’s transport regulator said on Sunday it would check all the airline’s A-321 planes, but Kogalymavia said this would not affect their operations.

Egypt’s civil aviation minister Hossam Kamal said there had been no sign of any problems on board the flight, contradicting earlier reports that the pilot had asked to make an emergency landing.

An Egyptian ground service official who carried out a pre-flight inspection of the plane said the aircraft appeared to be in good shape

“We are all shocked. It was a good plane. Everything checked out in 35 minutes,” the official told AP.

However, the widow of the plane’s co-pilot told Russian TV her husband had complained about the aircraft’s technical condition.

The plane was carrying 217 passengers, including 25 children, Russian transport authorities said. There were seven crew members on board.

Most of the passengers were Russian, but at least three were Ukrainian and one Belarusian.

A plane returning 162 bodies to Russia left Cairo late on Sunday, an airport official said. (BBC News)


A Russian passenger jet broke into pieces in midair, a top aviation official said Sunday, but he said it was too soon to say what could have caused the crash in Egypt’s Sinai Peninsula.

The plane crash Saturday morning killed all 224 people aboard Kogalymavia Flight 9268 and left debris strewn across a remote area of a region plagued by a violent Islamic insurgency.

“Disintegration of the fuselage took place in the air, and the fragments are scattered around a large area (about 20 square kilometers),” Viktor Sorochenko, executive director of Russia’s Interstate Aviation Committee, told journalists, according to reports.

Footage from the scene showed mangled wreckage and piles of belongings from the plane spilled over a largely flat, barren landscape.

Learning that the plane broke into pieces while in the air helps narrow down what could have caused the crash, but there are still plenty of possibilities, one expert said Sunday.

“It narrows it down a little bit, but there are a number of issues that could have affected this plane,” said Peter Goelz, a CNN aviation analyst and former managing director of the U.S. National Transportation Safety Board. “And terrorism has not been ruled out.

“It could have been some sort of catastrophic failure, perhaps caused by an earlier maintenance problem. It could have been a center fuel tank that might have exploded. They’re going to have to go back through the entire maintenance history of this plane to see whether all the corrections and repairs that had been ordered have been done.”

According to the Aviation Safety Network, which tracks aviation incidents, the same plane’s tail struck a runway while landing in Cairo in 2001 and required repair. At the time, the aircraft was operated by another carrier.

While authorities investigated what caused Saturday’s crash, mourners paid their respects to victims at a makeshift memorial Sunday at Pulkovo Airport in St. Petersburg, where the aircraft was supposed to end its journey.

Russian officials said that another plane — this one carrying the remains of up to 162 of the crash victims — took off from Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt, on Sunday and is heading to St. Petersburg.

‘It suddenly disappeared’

It remains unclear what caused Flight 9268 to drop off radar and hurtle to the ground, in clear weather and just 23 minutes after taking off from Sharm el-Sheikh.

Speaking to high-ranking army officers in Cairo on Sunday, Egyptian President Abdel Fattah el-Sisi asked them to observe a moment of silence before urging the public not to jump to conclusions. Determining what happened will require a lengthy investigation, he said.

“These are complicated matters that require advanced technologies and wide investigations that might go on for months,” he said.

The crash is most likely the result of a technical failure, Egyptian Airports Co. chief Adel Al-Mahjoob told CNN Arabic on Saturday, although he noted that the plane passed a routine check before it took off.

Russian media outlets said that the pilot reported technical problems and requested a landing at the nearest airport before the plane went missing, but Egyptian authorities disputed that claim.

Air traffic control recordings don’t show any distress calls, Egyptian Civil Aviation Minister Hossam Kamel said at a news conference.

“There was nothing abnormal before the plane crash,” he said. “It suddenly disappeared from the radar.”

Russia’ state-run NTV news channel interviewed the co-pilot’s ex-wife, who said he’d told their daughter he was concerned about the technical condition of the plane.

“Our daughter had a telephone chat with him just before the flight,” Natalya Trukhacheva said. “He complained before the flight that one could wish for better technical condition of the plane.”